Fantasy News & Analysis

Fantasy football stats: 20 players who were underrated before the 2018 season

Nashville, TN, USA; Seattle Seahawks running back Chris Carson (32) runs for a touchdown during during the second half against the Tennessee Titans at Nissan Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-USA TODAY Sports

Who were the most underrated players in fantasy football for the 2018-2019 NFL season? Fantasy football is an imperfect science, and while our goal is always to provide you with the best, most accurate analysis backed by data-driven thinking, we can’t always be right.

So who did we miss on in 2018?


Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs

Preseason: QB14; Actual: QB1

Why we should have seen this coming: Mahomes started the preseason with a 69-yard touchdown pass to Tyreek Hill in triple coverage. After connecting with Hill on all 14 targets in the preseason, we should’ve seen this from a mile away.

Matt Ryan, Atlanta Falcons

Preseason: QB15; Actual: QB2

Why we should have seen this coming: Ryan was just one season removed from his MVP performance in 2016, and the Falcons added a first-round wide receiver in last year’s draft.

Jared Goff, Los Angeles Rams

Preseason: QB16; Actual: QB6

Why we should have seen this coming: Goff took a big leap in 2017 to finish as the No. 11 fantasy quarterback. In hindsight, why did we expect him to regress when all of the offensive pieces and head coach remained the same?

Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys

Preseason: QB19; Actual: QB10

Why we should have seen this coming: Dallas had a depleted group of outside weapons, but Prescott’s rushing ability should have been enough to keep him in play as a tail-end QB1.

Andrew Luck, Indianapolis Colts

Preseason: QB9; Actual: QB5

Why we should have seen this coming: Luck was a top-six fantasy quarterback every other fully healthy year of his career save for his rookie season (when he was eighth).

Running backs

James White, New England Patriots

Preseason: RB37; Actual: RB7

Why we should have seen this coming: White ranked 12th in fantasy points per touch in 2017 and the Patriots backfield the second-softest schedule on a per-touch basis heading into 2018.

Chris Carson, Seattle Seahawks

Preseason: RB42; Actual: RB15

Why we should have seen this coming: Seattle’s backfield was clearly unsettled as the season drew near, and Carson had displayed big upside in limited time in 2017.

Adrian Peterson, Washington Redskins

Preseason: RB45; Actual: RB19

Why we should have seen this coming: Washington had no real threat to Peterson in terms of rushing attempts. Oh, and Peterson is potentially not even human.

Tarik Cohen, Chicago Bears

Preseason: RB29; Actual: RB11

Why we should have seen this coming: Cohen was RB32 as an explosive rookie. Why we didn’t expect him to improve in Year 2 with Matt Nagy calling the shots was a clear oversight.

Christian McCaffrey, Carolina Panthers

Preseason: RB11; Actual: RB2

Why we should have seen this coming: McCaffrey was shooting up draft boards, but we certainly didn’t see RB2 coming. Carolina’s insistence on using him as a workhorse — and then doing so early in the preseason — should have been enough to move McCaffrey into the top 10, at a minimum.

Wide receivers

JuJu Smith-Schuster, Pittsburgh Steelers

Preseason: WR21; Actual: WR8

Why we should have seen this coming: Smith-Schuster was WR21 as a 21-year-old rookie. It’s hard to know why exactly we didn’t expect him to improve on that, but we should have. There’s now a legitimate question for 2019: Do you draft Smith-Schuster or Antonio Brown first?

Tyreek Hill, Kansas City Chiefs

Preseason: WR15; Actual: WR3

Why we should have seen this coming: As noted above, Hill caught 14-of-14 targets with Mahomes in the preseason, including some impressive deep balls that were quite literally uncoverable.

Julian Edelman, New England Patriots

Preseason: WR42; Actual: WR22

Why we should have seen this coming: Edelman’s four-game suspension to start the season was overrated. From Weeks 5-17, Edelman was a top-10 fantasy receiver. Lesson learned: Stop overreacting to early-season suspensions.

Calvin Ridley, Atlanta Falcons

Preseason: WR57; Actual: WR20

Why we should have seen this coming: The Falcons spent a first-round pick on Ridley and added him to an offense that lit the league on fire in 2016 — and still had most of those key pieces in place for 2018.

Tyler Lockett, Seattle Seahawks

Preseason: WR52; Actual: WR16

Why we should have seen this coming: In some ways, we did, and Lockett was a positive touchdown regression candidate leading into 2018. (And now he’s a negative touchdown regression candidate for 2019, for what it’s worth.)

Tight ends

Eric Ebron, Indianapolis Colts

Preseason: TE18; Actual: TE4

Why we should have seen this coming: Nobody could have seen this coming, but there were some positive signs: Luck’s return, the lack of weapons outside of T.Y. Hilton, and Frank Reich at head coach, who had grown accustomed to using Zach Ertz in Philadelphia.

George Kittle, San Francisco 49ers

Preseason: TE13; Actual: TE3

Why we should have seen this coming: Kittle flashed big-play ability and elite athleticism as a rookie in 2017. We should’ve given him top-10 treatment with Jimmy Garoppolo under center. Imagine what he’ll do next season with Garoppolo actually healthy.

Jared Cook, Oakland Raiders

Preseason: TE16; Actual: TE5

Why we should have seen this coming: Cook had a healthy 83 targets in 2017, third on the team and not far behind the first- (99) and second- (90) most-targeted players on the team — one of whom (Michael Crabtree) was no longer there to start 2018.

O.J. Howard, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Preseason: TE20; Actual: TE15

Why we should have seen this coming: Howard was on pace for a potential top-five season, and we should have known to draft him higher than TE20 given Tampa’s pass-happy approach.

David Njoku, Cleveland Browns

Preseason: TE12; Actual: TE9

Why we should have seen this coming: The former first-round pick was primed for a big step forward from a decent rookie season. He scored twice in the preseason opener, too, showing that he was indeed ready for a bigger role in the offense.


Unlock the 2023 Fantasy Draft Kit, with League Sync, Live Draft Assistant, PFF Grades & Data Platform that powers all 32 Pro Teams

$31 Draft Kit Fee + $8.99/mo
$89.88/yr + FREE Draft Kit