New England Patriots
- Pass Game Supporting Cast – Tier 2
- Overall Team Supporting Cast – Tier 1
[Editor’s note: The Supporting Cast metrics measure performance of players other than the quarterback, utilizing PFF grades and clustering analysis to group them into tiers from best (Tier 1) to worst (Tier 4). Passing Game Supporting Cast is indicative of supporting players contributing more to passing stats while Overall Team Supporting Cast includes other portions of team performance as well. For more information on support cast rankings, listen in weekly to the PFF Forecast podcast.]
In Boston, the Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski contract talks, as well as Julian Edelman’s four-game suspension seem to be all Boston-based media can talk about despite the New England Patriots coming off their third Super Bowl appearance in four years.
As tantalizing as these topics may be, there’s much more to discuss with regards to New England’s 2018 campaign, including who will replace Danny Amendola in the slot and Malcolm Butler as the Patriots’ second cornerback among others.
The McCourty brothers unite
While many of course would have liked to see him play in the Super Bowl against the Philadelphia Eagles, 2017 was a tough year for Butler. Among all cornerbacks, he regressed slightly, finishing with a 79.2 overall grade, ranking 51st being ranking fifth in 2016 and 18th in 2015. He also gave up six touchdowns in his coverage, tying for third-most at the position, while also yielding the 11th-most yards at 698 and ranking 108th in yards after the catch at 233.
New England simply couldn’t afford to match the five-year, $61-million contract the Tennessee Titans gave Butler this offseason, especially with Trey Flowers, Shaq Mason and Chris Hogan set to be free agents in 2019, as well as Brady, Gronkowski, Devin McCourty and Julian Edelman in 2020.
Enter Jason McCourty from the Cleveland Browns in exchange for the Patriots’ 2018 sixth-round pick. In overall grade, McCourty ranked 27th in overall grade during the 2017 season, and 53rd in 2016 while finishing 32nd in coverage grade and 11th against the run. McCourty didn’t miss a single tackle all season long, and his combined tackling efficiency among cornerbacks with 300 snaps ranked second.
McCourty enters the Patriots defense knowing his twin brother Devin will be starting at free safety behind him, while also knowing Stephon Gilmore, the team’s third-highest graded returning player from last season, will likely be starting opposite him.
Replacing Danny “Playoff” Amendola
The Patriots’ leading candidate to replace Amendola is Jordan Matthews, who finished the season with a well-below average overall grade of 41.7. Injuries plagued him last season, eventually leading to an injured reserve trip from knee issues, but Matthews did play in 10 games and was only targeted 35 times. He also tied for 71st with just two missed tackles forced, 86th in yards per catch at 11.3 and 103rd in blocking.
To Matthews’ credit, he did thrive in the slot, finishing ranked ninth with a 73.9 percent catch rate from an inside alignment, right behind Amendola. Going back to his outstanding rookie year, Matthews’ catch rate ranked 20th at 68.1 percent and his eight touchdowns and 64 receptions in the slot each ranked second.
The Patriots selected a pair of Georgia Bulldogs in the first round of the 2018 NFL Draft who could very well start at their respective positions in left guard/tackle Isaiah Wynn, taken 23rd overall and RB Sony Michel, who heard his name called at Pick 31.
Wynn graded as the second-best left tackle in all of college football last season. He really shined as a run-blocker, finishing with the second-highest run-blocking grade but he was no slouch in pass protection either, as he didn’t give up a single hit on the quarterback, and relinquished just three pressures all season long. Wynn will compete to takeover for Nate Solder, who signed with the New York Giants this offseason, with former 2015 seventh-round selection Trent Brown. The 6-foot-8, 380-pound Brown was acquired from the San Francisco 49ers for the 95th overall choice back in April.
Michel ranked 22nd overall during his final season in Athens, splitting time with Nick Chubb limited him to just 354 snaps but he still managed to tie for fourth in yards per carry at 8.1, 27th in yards after contact per attempt and tied for 44th in missed tackles with 35.
For more on Sony Michel, Isaiah Wynn and the rest of the 2018 NFL Draft class – it’s not too late to grab the 2018 NFL Draft Guide –
There’s a level of uncertainty in New England that rivals any year in the past. Left tackle and cornerback depth are question marks, as is linebacker depth. However, given their track record of discovering diamonds in the rough, this team looks as poised as ever for a deep playoff run.
They’ll just have to iron out a few details in training camp.
POSITION BATTLES TO WATCH
- Wide receiver depth, position – Malcolm Mitchell, Braxton Berrios, Cordarrelle Patterson, Phillip Dorsett, Kenny Britt, Riley McCarron
- RB Mike Gillislee fighting for his roster spot
- Dwayne Allen keeping his position as back-up tight end
- Depth at cornerback – Cyrus Jones vs Keion Crossen vs J.C. Jackson vs Ryan Lewis vs Duke Dawson
- Back quarterback – Danny Etling vs Brian Hoyer
2018 PFF NFL Training Camp Previews
Arizona Cardinals | Atlanta Falcons | Baltimore Ravens | Buffalo Bills | Carolina Panthers | Chicago Bears | Cincinnati Bengals | Cleveland Browns | Dallas Cowboys | Denver Broncos | Detroit Lions | Green Bay Packers | Houston Texans | Indianapolis Colts | Jacksonville Jaguars | Kansas City Chiefs | Los Angeles Chargers | Los Angeles Rams | Miami Dolphins | Minnesota Vikings | New England Patriots | New Orleans Saints | New York Giants | New York Jets | Oakland Raiders | Philadelphia Eagles | Pittsburgh Steelers | Seattle Seahawks | San Francisco 49ers | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Tennessee Titans | Washington Redskins