NFL News & Analysis

Ranking the rookie preseason debuts of the top quarterbacks from the 2022 NFL Draft

Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Kenny Pickett (8) throws a pass against the Seattle Seahawks during the fourth quarter at Acrisure Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Philip G. Pavely-USA TODAY Sports

• The Pittsburgh Steelers' Kenny Pickett, despite sticking with shorter passes for most of his debut, was efficient with the football and lands at No. 1.

• It was a preseason debut to forget for the Carolina Panthers' Matt Corral, who went just 1-of-9 en route to a 35.8 passing grade.

• The New England Patriots' Bailey Zappe handled the Giants' frequent blitzes well in his rookie debut, pushing him into the No. 2 spot here.

The NFL preseason debuts for the 2022 quarterback class went about as expected. In a quarterback class hailed for its lack of NFL-readiness, many of the top-six drafted signal-callers took their lumps early on. That being said, there were reasons to be encouraged from most, as well. Let’s stack up the debuts from each:

6. Matt Corral, Carolina Panthers (RD 3, Pick 94)

Corral’s debut is what it looks like when a rookie simply isn’t up to speed yet in an NFL offense. He was missing layup throws that he wouldn’t have thought twice about at Ole Miss.

You could see the wheels turning a thousand times a second in his brain as he was dropping back. It didn’t help that there were numerous free rushers due to protection errors, but even that doesn’t come close to explaining away his performance. Corral finished 1-of-9 for 11 yards on 13 dropbacks with three sacks and a 35.8 passing grade. Burn the tape. 

5. Sam Howell, Washington Commanders (RD 5, Pick 144)

Howell came out guns blazing in his preseason debut. His first few passes had some serious mustard on them. After getting a little greedy on a far-hash out that was nearly picked off, Howell settled in and looked like the downfield passer we saw at North Carolina. He had both a perfectly placed go-ball and an on-time backside dig under pressure on the same drive early in the fourth quarter. 

Howell capped off that drive with a 17-yard scamper for a score in what was the most impressive drive from a rookie I saw over the weekend.  

Why he falls at No. 5 on this list, though, is because he still turfed a few throws that should have been hit and displayed shaky pocket presence. He probably played better than his 39.0 passing grade indicates, but we’d definitely look at his stat line differently if his two turnover-worthy plays were caught instead of dropped by defenders.

4. Malik Willis, Tennessee Titans (RD 3, Pick 86)

Willis once again showed off the traits that made him QB1 on the final PFF draft board. There’s no question that the athlete and the arm are high-end-caliber for the position in the NFL.

As far as playing the quarterback position, however, Willis has a ways to go. The school-yard football that Willis was prone to at Liberty showed up once again for the Titans. Of his 18 dropbacks, seven resulted in either a sack or a scramble (38.9%) That is a drastically unsustainable rate in the NFL. In fact, head coach Mike Vrabel stated after the game that he was so perturbed by Willis’ unwillingness to let it rip that he pulled his rookie quarterback in the second half for that reason.

With Willis, it’s going to be about balance. Yes, he needs to operate from the pocket more in the NFL game. But at the same time, you won’t get electric plays like the one below if you reel him in too much.

3. Desmond Ridder, Atlanta Falcons (RD 3, Pick 74)

Ridder’s performance wasn’t nearly as ugly as his 10-of-22 for 103 yards stat line may suggest. One reason is that those numbers don’t include the 54 yards he picked up on the ground. 

The other is that he was barely off on a number of big-play opportunities. While ball placement was one of Ridder's biggest knocks coming out of Cincinnati, his misses weren’t egregious and he erred on the safe side for the most part. Ridder led all rookies with three drops from his receivers, resulting in 32 air yards lost. With starting receivers, his stat line would have looked considerably better.

The biggest takeaway from Ridder’s debut was simply how comfortable he looked. The panic you often see from rookies when they facing free rushers or collapsing pockets wasn’t present with Ridder. He was the only rookie this past week not to take a sack and he did so on nine pressured dropbacks. The crispness of his fakes and footwork does not look like that of a rookie.

He showed a high-level understanding for the position at the end of both halves. In the first half, he threw it away when nothing was there to stop the clock for a field goal. And at the end of the game, he gave his guy a chance when it was fourth down. Those are all very good signs if you’re a Falcons fan.  

2. Bailey Zappe, New England Patriots (RD 4, Pick 137)

It took Zappe a while to settle in, but once he did, he looked much the same decisive pocket passer we saw last season at Western Kentucky. The ball was routinely coming out once he hit his back foot, which is not something you see every day from a rookie in their debut. His 2.27-second average time to throw was not only the quickest of any rookie, but also the second-fastest of any quarterback in the first week of the preseason.

Of his 33 dropbacks, only one utilized a play-action fake. That was in response to Wink Martindale blitzing on over 50% of Zappe’s dropbacks — something that Bill Belichick didn’t take kindly to.  

And the thing is, Zappe handled the blitz very well. On those 17 dropbacks, he went 12-of-16 for 135 yards with a touchdown and an interception. Handling that kind of heat and not flinching too badly is certainly the mark of an encouraging debut for the rookie. 

1. Kenny Pickett, Pittsburgh Steelers (RD 1, Pick 20)

The stat line tells you all you need to know about the difficulty of the throws Pickett was making. He went 13-of-15 for 95 yards (6.3 YPA) with a 5.5-yard average depth of target and a 3.3-yard average depth of completion.

That being said, Pickett’s command of the offense stood out immediately. He was quick and efficient with the football, averaging a solid 2.75-second time to throw. Pickett also flashed his mobility with three scrambles for 16 yards.

The level of difficulty simply wasn’t there, though, to make too many sweeping judgments. If you watch the highlights below, you’ll see that it was pretty much all underneath stuff until the game-winning score (3:16 into the clip)

There’s obviously no shame in taking what the defense gives you, but there’s a big difference between what third-string defenses will give you in preseason versus what NFL starters will give you in the regular season. That's why Pickett's passing grade still finished at a middling 63.9 for the day.


Unlock the 2023 Fantasy Draft Kit, with League Sync, Live Draft Assistant, PFF Grades & Data Platform that powers all 32 Pro Teams

$31 Draft Kit Fee + $8.99/mo
$89.88/yr + FREE Draft Kit