MitchMcCarthy

PP#44IND Hoosiers

6'5" • 233lbs • Sr.

Draft Eligibility:2026

Overall Grade '25: 60.3; 150th/209 - Ps
Punts '25: 24; 203rd/209 - Ps
Punt Net Avg. '25: 37.33; 141st/209 - Ps

Mitch

McCarthy

#44

IND Hoosiers

BIO

GRADES

SEASON STATS

Mock Draft Simulator

Summary Bio

Last updated: 10/28/2026

Mitch McCarthy was a punter for the Indiana Hoosiers who earned a 60.3 PFF punting grade in the 2025 season, 150th among 209 qualified punters. He punted 24 times with a net average of 37.3 yards per punt and a long of 52 yards.

McCarthy pinned opponents inside the 20-yard line 8 times, reflecting his directional control. He averaged 3.64 seconds of hang time per punt.

His punts resulted in 0 touchbacks, 6 fair catches, 5 downed punts.

Career

Teams

Year

Hamilton Tiger-Cats

2026

Indiana Hoosiers

2025

UCF Knights

2022 - 2024

PFF Grades

2025

Regular

Players receive a ranking if they qualify 25% of the maximum targets, run attempts or dropbacks at the position (depending on the metric).

PUNT

60.3

AVG

150th/209 Ps

KICKOFF

N/S

AVG

Not Enough Snaps

Highest Graded Games

vsVAOD

N/S

Week 1, 2025

vsILUN

N/S

Week 4, 2025

@IAUN

N/S

Week 5, 2025

Lowest Graded Games

vsVAOD

N/S

Week 1, 2025

vsILUN

N/S

Week 4, 2025

@IAUN

N/S

Week 5, 2025

Grades by Game

View in Premium Stats

Premium Stats

There's no Grades by Game data available for this player.

Season Stats

2025

Regular

Players receive a ranking if they qualify 25% of the maximum targets, run attempts or dropbacks at the position (depending on the metric).

PUNTS

203rd/209 Ps

PUNT NET AVG.

37.33

141st/209 Ps

LONG

196th/209 Ps

PINNED INSIDE THE 20

196th/209 Ps

Punting

View in Premium Stats

Rank

203

Punts

141

Punt Net Avg.

37.33

196

Long

196

Pinned Inside the 20

Return %

37.5%

104

Yards per Return

Touchbacks

Downed

Out of Bounds

192

Fair Catches

151

Hang Time Avg.

3.64

Kickoffs

View in Premium Stats

Rank

Kicks Returned

Kicks Returned %

Yards per Return

Average Field Position